Holding is easier than lifting
A heat pump that keeps a pool at 28 °C through a mild week is doing far less work than one trying to lift a cold pool by six degrees before a weekend. The second job needs either a larger unit or more time.
This is why commissioning readings and a realistic expectation matter. If you know the unit will lift the pool by a degree a day in autumn, you can plan around it instead of being disappointed.
The cover matters more than the badge
Most of a pool's heat loss is evaporative, and an uncovered pool on a windy Cape evening loses far more than the heat pump can add overnight. A cover changes the required duty more than any equipment upgrade.
Wind exposure and shade also change the picture. A pool in a sheltered, sunny garden holds temperature with a much smaller unit than an exposed one.
Winter is a different question
Output falls as air temperature drops, and Cape winter nights are cold and wet. Running a heat pump through midwinter is possible but expensive relative to the swimming you get.
Most owners get better value by holding temperature into autumn, letting the pool drift in the coldest weeks and bringing it back in spring. That is an honest use of the equipment rather than a failure of it.